[DAO:68e3b0e] DCL Global Recruiting & Onboarding Marketing Campaign Phygital T-shirt Contest

Hi again, @CheddarQueso. Hope you’ve had a great week. Responses to your follow-up questions are below:

All of the information you are requesting is subject to the proposal passing. Think about it like this - imagine someone who is unemployed with no savings reaching out to an establishment to book an event with no money, no set date of when funds will be available to put down a deposit or of the event as they are awaiting a decision from a potential employer, or any other relevant financial details. The place will say “call back when you have that figured out”. That’s where we are at. Given this is a Sponsorship proposal, the IRL event is necessary to even qualify for this category so we definitely will be holding this event.

The wonderful thing about this platform is that grantees must meet with the Grant Support Squad (GSS) on a monthly basis show proof that the team has been tracking towards their roadmap. If we are unable to deliver, then there are ramifications. The GSS and community will also receive updates on the proposal monthly and can ask questions within the Discord. There are so many avenues to ensure performance.

The shirts will be given away and are the phygital assets as they are a physical item tied with a NFC tag that links to the DCL website. The wearables are going to be sold on the marketplace and are digital products. The shirts are the physical product tied to a digital marketing effort via the NFC tag.

If you believe I am contradicting myself, then my apologies for the misunderstanding as that is not my intention. To clarify, the event will be open to developers and designers worldwide regardless of their experience in DCL.

As for the IRL event, I’ve responded above so will not revisit the question here, however, please advise of any further questions.

Respectfully, we do not agree that the approach shared by Peanutbutta as it isn’t taking into account all the facets and goals of our projects. If all we wanted was a t-shirt with a DCL logo, perhaps one can take his proposed route. We, however, are not simply looking to distribute shirts. The shirts are the result of the efforts, the tangible item people can walk away with.

Open sourcing a design, as recommended by Peanutbutta, places the onus on the individual. Not only would they have to invest their own time and money to produce the t-shirt, but many might be deterred by the inconvenience or costs, resulting in significantly fewer brand ambassadors. Our approach is both practical and effective, ensuring that DCL’s presence is seen and cohesively represented worldwide.

While the simplicity of open sourcing a design for local print shops may seem appealing, it fundamentally lacks the cohesive branding, quality assurance, and ethical standards that our project ensures. Local print shops vary significantly in terms of quality, ethical sourcing, and adherence to brand guidelines which leads to inconsistent representations of the DCL brand.

Our project ensures that ever t-shirt looks and feels premium and is also produced under ethical conditions.

Ultimately, the DCL community deserves more than an inconsistent representation of its brand. Our proposal is about creating a unified, high-quality, and ethically produced brand representation that both the DCL community and the artists involved can be proud of. We’ve created an engaging contest coupled with a global recruiting and onboarding effort and IRL event where the platform and product will be showcased and shared with the attendees, respectively.

This is not the definition of a phygital item. Respectfully, I don’t mean to be rude, but you are misrepresenting what you are giving the community. A physical item with an NFC tag that ties to a website is not a phygital. The item must exist in the owner’s wallet as a wearable NFT wich is usable by their digital avatar in the same way the physical item is used.

I caution the community against relying on the GSS and the revocations committee to recoup any lost funds due to unmet deliverables. In most cases, a large amount of funds has already been disbursed, we don’t find out about unmet goals until update times, and in the time the GSS finishes their investigations, and the Revocations Committee makes their decision, money is being wasted. Let’s learn from our past lessons.

There is an open proposal to pause grants again. It is obvious from the overall community sentiment in the Discord and here, that after resuming grants, we have continued to hemorrhage money at grants that do not bring value, many of them passed under suspicious or outright nefarious voting practices.

Thank you for your responses @MelzBuenaVibes, you are very thorough and professional and I respect your opinion.

Hello again, @CheddarQueso. Thanks for the prompt reply.

Respectfully, I am not misrepresenting anything. This may be the definition you and others may use, but that is not the definition of a phygital product. Please see the below definition found on collectid.io.

A Phygital Product is a Physical Product That Has an Association With a Digital Component, Such As an App or Website.

Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this matter. Again, our goal is to do something innovative and different from what’s been done before. Certainly, you are entitled to your thoughts about the budget and initiative, however, we would like to remove ourselves from the sentiments you’ve shared regarding other projects. We can only speak for ourselves.

I have always taken my reputation seriously - academically, professionally, and even personally. I’ve excelled in goals and projects I’ve worked on. Outside of DCL, I’m a manager at a management consulting firm where I guide my team in optimizing processes for Fortune 100 companies, saving them money with ROI guarantees tied to my project’s results. I, along with my partner Julio, have shared my full identity here. Comparing our project to project’s unrelated to ours, respectively, is not the right approach.

I urge the community to consider our background, project, and the value we plan to bring as opposed to comparing us to projects and people we do not associate with or even know. Please read our full proposal and ask us any questions that may provide more information and context around our scope of work.

Thanks, @CheddarQueso, for the dialogue and sharing your thoughts. I respect the manner in which you’ve addressed me, the team, and our project. You are an example I would like to highlight to others in the community. I encourage others to take this same approach when reviewing and providing feedback to projects people sometimes take months to create.

DCL Global Recruiting & Onboarding Marketing Campaign Phygital T-shirt Contest

This proposal is now in status: REJECTED.

Voting Results:

  • Yes 34% 5,271,152 VP (45 votes)
  • No 59% 8,964,360 VP (64 votes)
  • Abstain 7% 1,163,629 VP (12 votes)