[DAO: Qmb1QeX] Delist Decentral Games Backgammon from Map @ -101, -70 as it sits disconnected from server for over a year

Governance
1

by 0x26ce3ceff8f60b40af237a2d5a11e4e81f0bc606 (Leezee)

Decentral Games what are you doing with this land? Do you even still own it. This is why I was in favor of delisting dormant map points-of-interest in a poll that lost.

DECENTRAL GAMES, WHATS THE DEAL WITH -101, -70 ???

  • DELIST
  • KEEP AS IS
  • Invalid question/options

Vote on this proposal on the Decentraland DAO

View this proposal on Snapshot

2

Delist Decentral Games Backgammon from Map @ -101, -70 as it sits disconnected from server for over a year…

This proposal is now in status: FINISHED.

Voting Results:

  • Delist 99% 524,824 VP (59 votes)
  • Keep as is 1% 4,075 VP (1 votes)
  • Invalid question/options 0% 0 VP (0 votes)
3

Hi, I’m Gino from the DAO Governance Squad. A few weeks ago we launched an update on the Governance dApp that let the users to publish a “Remove POI” proposal. That is a binding category, meaning that as opposed to a Poll, the results are enacted by the DAO Committee after it passed. You can go ahead and make a new proposal using that category linking to this one if you want.

4

Looks like it’s not possible to remove that POI from the governance dapp because it’s not listed in the POI smart contract.

The original implementation of POI was defined as a list controlled by DCL Foundation. You can check this list here: https://config.decentraland.org/explorer.json. It currently declares 90 Points of Interest.

Once the DAO and POI List smart contract were set up the client team started to honor both the centralized list and the smart contract listing. IMO it’s time to deprecate the centralized list.

A soft transition could start by migrating the 90 POIs from the centralized list to the smart contract and ask the client team to stop consuming that list. This way all POIs will continue but new proposals to delete them will work as expected. The problem is this operation will require adding 90 POIs at an estimated gas fee of 200 USD each, totaling ~$18.000 USD expense just to keep old POIs.

A more straightforward path is to stop using the centralized list and remove all 90 POIs at once. Then it will be up to the community/land-owners to start a vote to include them back.

5

Delist Decentral Games Backgammon from Map @ -101, -70 as it sits disconnected from server for over a year…

This proposal has been PASSED by a DAO Committee Member (0xfe91c0c482e09600f2d1dbca10fd705bc6de60bc)